Chapter 5 - The Deposition of LiesTwo months later.
The grand conference room on the top floor of the St. Catherine’s Administrative Center overlooked the entire hospital campus.
At the end of the long glass table sat Dr. Robert Harrison. He was flanked by four senior defense partners from the city’s largest corporate law firm. Harrison was dressed in an expensive navy suit, his silver hair neatly styled, his posture rigid with supreme arrogance.
Across from him sat Mercer, Sarah Lopez, and me.
A court reporter sat at the corner of the table, her fingers poised over her stenography machine.
“Let the record reflect,” Mercer began, opening his file, “that this is the videotaped deposition of Dr. Robert Harrison in the matter of Marissa Brooks, Executor of the Estate of Aaron Brooks, versus St. Catherine’s Health System.”
Harrison adjusted his gold cufflink, looking at me with a practiced, sympathetic tilt of his head.
“Mrs. Brooks,” Harrison said smoothly, addressing the camera. “Before we begin, I want to express my deepest personal condolences for your loss. Aaron’s death was an unprecedented medical tragedy. But as a physician with twenty-five years of emergency medicine experience, I must reiterate that an acute aortic dissection is an unpredictable, catastrophic event that no hospital can prevent.”
“Thank you for that speech, Dr. Harrison,” Mercer interrupted dryly. “Now let’s talk about murder.”
The chief defense lawyer slammed his hand on the table. “Objection! Counsel will refrain from inflammatory, baseless accusations!”
“I’ll withdraw the word 'murder' for now,” Mercer said with a cold smile. “Let's use 'depraved indifference manslaughter' instead.”
Mercer pulled a laminated document from his folder and slid it across the glass table to Harrison.
“Dr. Harrison, please identify Plaintiff’s Exhibit 14.”
Harrison looked down at the paper. For a fraction of a second, his left eyelid twitched.
“It appears to be a internal facilities work order from March,” Harrison said smoothly, sliding it back. “I review hundreds of administrative papers a week. I have no specific recollection of this document.”
“Read the handwritten note at the bottom, Doctor,” Mercer commanded.
Harrison leaned back, crossing his arms. “I decline to read it out loud.”
“Then I’ll read it for you,” Mercer said, his voice echoing through the silent room. “'Work order rejected due to patient volume capacity requirements. Temporary stabilization authorized. Keep room in rotation. Signed, Dr. Robert Harrison.'”
“Administrative decisions regarding bed capacity are complex—” Harrison began.
“Let’s move to Plaintiff’s Exhibit 15,” Mercer interrupted, sliding a secondary folder across the table.
This folder contained printed copies of text messages retrieved from Arthur Vance’s phone:
Harrison (March 22, 10:14 PM): 'I don't care if the bracket is rusted through, Arthur. Tape the damn thing up. If Room Six goes offline tonight, corporate cuts our quarterly bonus pool. Fix it or start looking for another job.'
Harrison’s face went instantly pale. He looked at his lead defense attorney, whose arrogant composure had completely shattered.
“Where... where did you get this?” Harrison stammered, his polished facade cracking wide open.
“We got it from Arthur Vance,” Mercer revealed, leaning forward over the table. “Along with the audio recording of your risk management department offering him a fifty-thousand-dollar bribe to lie to the state health inspectors.”
The lead defense attorney immediately reached over and covered the microphone. “We need a fifteen-minute recess. Right now.”
“No recess, Counselor,” Mercer roared, standing up from his chair and pointing a finger directly at Harrison’s trembling face. “Your client is under active criminal investigation by the Rhode Island Attorney General’s Office. Two state investigators are standing outside those glass doors right now with a warrant for his arrest!”
Harrison jumped out of his leather chair, his hands shaking so violently he nearly knocked over his water glass.
“It wasn't just me!” Harrison yelled, his professional composure completely disintegrating into frantic panic. “The board set those patient volume metrics! Corporate told us that if our emergency room wait times exceeded forty minutes, our funding would be cut by fifteen percent! I was running a hospital with half a staff and a board that only cared about profit margins! I didn't mean for the fan to kill him!”
“You put a man suffering an aortic tear under a rusted three-hundred-pound weapon so you could hit a financial bonus,” I said, standing up to face him directly.
Harrison looked at me, his eyes wide with desperate pleading. “Mrs. Brooks... please...”
“Do not say my husband’s name,” I hissed, my voice cutting through him like a blade. “You didn't just kill Aaron, Doctor. You tried to erase him. You tried to make the world believe that he died because he was weak, because his body failed him. But his body didn't fail him. You failed him. Your hospital failed him. And now, you are going to pay for every single second he suffered in that room.”
The glass double doors of the conference room swung open.
Two state police detectives walked into the room, handcuffs already drawn.
May you like
“Dr. Robert Harrison?” the lead detective asked. “You are under arrest for second-degree manslaughter, obstruction of justice, and conspiracy to tamper with physical evidence.”
The room went completely silent as the police pulled the Chief of Emergency Medicine’s hands behind his back and snapped the silver cuffs around his wrists. The man who had spent his career treating patients like disposable numbers was led away in tears, his expensive suit rumpled, his career and freedom destroyed forever.
