Chapter 1 - The Mirror ImageMom walked into the kitchen carrying two brown paper bags from the boutique grocery store in downtown Lexington. Her cheeks were flushed pink from the damp February wind, and her keys made their familiar, sharp jingling sound against the marble kitchen island.
"Look who’s home!" Mom said, her voice lilting into that practiced, cheerful cadence she used whenever she felt an audience needed settling. "Morgan, honey, put the kettle on. We have the biggest surprise."
Behind her, the hallway floorboards creaked.
I set down the quarterly budget reports I had been reviewing for the municipal water board. The overhead pendant light buzzed faintly against the winter twilight.
Then Elise stepped around the corner into the kitchen.
My breath stopped in the middle of my throat.
Elise was looking directly at the floor, her hands shoved so deep into the pockets of her camel-wool coat that the fabric pulled tight across her hips. When she finally raised her chin, my pulse jumped into my ears.
Her waist-length, honey-blonde hair—the thick, glossy mane our mother had brushed every Sunday night with a silver-backed boar-bristle brush since we were seven—was gone.
It hung in a blunt, angular line stopping exactly one-quarter inch below her earlobes. It was textured at the tips, parted slightly off-center to the left, and tucked behind her left ear to reveal a pair of small, gold hoop earrings identical to the ones I had bought myself three weeks ago.
The haircut was an exact, millimeter-accurate duplicate of mine.
"Ta-da!" Mom clapped her hands together once, a sharp, joyous sound that echoed off the white subway tile. "Isn't it marvelous? We went straight to see Andre at The French Cut. I brought along three photos from the kitchen that night after you got yours done so he could match the graduation of the layers perfectly. He had to use two different texturizing shears, but look at her! It’s like magic. My girls are whole again."
I stared at Elise.
Elise did not look marvelous. Her mouth was set in a tight, pale line that made the tiny dimple on her left cheek disappear. Her eyes—the exact hazel shade of mine, down to the fleck of amber beside the pupil—flickered toward the refrigerator, then to the tea kettle, then to the tips of her boots.
"You cut your hair," I said. The words came out flat, dry as paper.
"She did!" Mom beamed, already pulling cartons of organic raspberries and salted butter from the paper bags. "She was so brave. Weren't you, Ellie? When the first big braid came off, her eyes got a little misty, but I told her, 'Elise, think how sweet it will be when you two walk into the Easter service. Just like high school.' We stopped by Talbots on the way back and picked up two matching knit sweaters in sage green. They were having a pre-season promotion. I hung yours in your closet, Morgan."
"Elise," I repeated, ignoring Mom completely. "Did you want this?"
Elise swallowed. The tendon in her throat jumped.
For two seconds, the air in the kitchen was brittle enough to snap. I saw the hesitation in her eyes—the same hesitation she’d had when she looked down at the wet clay in the studio, the same pause before she admitted she wanted the Friday watercolor class.
Then Mom turned around from the counter, a block of cheddar cheese in her hand, her smile widening into that smooth, immovable wall she had used to govern our lives for twenty-four years.
"Of course she wanted it, Morgan," Mom said smoothly. "What kind of question is that? Twins share things. That’s what makes you special. You two have never been selfish girls. Now, did you start the water? I want to make that chamomile tea before dinner."
Elise finally spoke. Her voice was thin, small, and carefully pitched.
"It’s just hair, Morgy," she murmured, using the childhood nickname Mom had assigned to me to balance out Ellie. "It grows back. And... Mom’s right. It looks nice on both of us."
She gave me the smile.
The automatic, symmetrical, five-hundred-watt family smile that had graced sixteen consecutive years of Christmas cards, four local newspaper features on the "Miracle Vance Twins," and thousands of square images on social media.
A chill settled deep behind my ribs.
I looked at the sage green sweater peeking through the cracked door of the hallway pantry where Mom had hung the shopping bag. I looked at Elise’s neck—exposed, shivering slightly in the kitchen draft.
When I cut my hair three weeks ago, I thought I had taken a step toward being an individual. I thought I had drawn a tiny, modest line in the dirt: This is Morgan.
I had been an idiot.
To my mother, my haircut hadn't been an expression of selfhood; it had been a manufacturing defect. A temporary disruption in the assembly line. And she had spent two hundred dollars and four hours in an upscale salon just to pull the defective product back into compliance.
"I have to go," I said, sliding my laptop and files into my leather tote.
Mom’s smile faltered for a fraction of a second. "Go? Dinner is in thirty minutes. Scalloped potatoes, just the way you like them."
"I'm meeting a friend," I lied, pulling my coat from the banister.
"Which friend?" Mom’s voice instantly lost its lilting warmth, sharpening into that quiet, forensic tone she used whenever one of our schedules slipped outside her mental calendar. "You didn't put anything on the family whiteboard. Is it Sarah from church? Or someone from your accounting office?"
"Just a friend, Mom," I said, my hand on the brass doorknob.
"Morgan," Mom called after me, her footsteps clicking on the tile as she followed me into the foyer. "You’re acting very erratic lately. The gym, skipping dinner, running out without telling us where you're going. Elise doesn't act like this. You’re making your sister uncomfortable."
I paused on the threshold. The January wind whipped across my freshly shorn neck, cold and sharp.
Behind Mom stood Elise. She had taken off her coat. In her white t-shirt, with her hair chopped to match mine, standing under the hall chandelier, she looked like my reflection in a funhouse mirror.
She looked exhausted.
May you like
"Goodnight, Elise," I said.
Elise didn't answer. She just lifted one hand, gave a tiny, half-inch wave, and let her fingers drop back to her side as Mom closed the door between us.
Related Stories
